Customers say these holiday-themed squeaky toys are adorable and well-made, featuring festive designs in tartan plaid and cookie shapes. Many reviews mention the toys' cute appearance and quality construction, with dogs showing immediate attachment to them. Common feedback includes praise for the soft yet durable materials and pleasant squeaker sounds. While most find them perfect for small to medium dogs, some note concerns about size appropriateness for larger breeds. Reviews are mixed on durability, with several mentioning toys being destroyed quickly by heavy chewers, though others report surprising longevity. Frequent comments address their appeal as holiday gifts and stocking stuffers.